Technology

Free Adobe Clones Built With AI: Real Threat or Just a Demo?

Under The Headline
Under The Headline

3 min read

Last month a developer in Atlanta published seven free replacements for Adobe's most famous apps, and he says an AI model wrote them. The lineup has since grown to sixteen. Whether any of it is good enough to use is a separate question, and the answer says a lot about where software is heading.

What ArtCraft actually is

The project is the work of Brandon Thomas, and he has said Adobe's cancellation fees helped motivate it. The apps are native desktop programs written in Rust, with no Electron and no web views, and they run locally on your own files. They use MIT and Apache licenses.

The scope has grown fast. The first repositories appeared on September 30. The official site now lists sixteen apps, covering image editing, video, page layout, word processing, spreadsheets, presentations, audio and CAD.

The claim: written by an AI

Thomas says he built the apps with help from Anthropic's Claude Opus 5.5. One outlet notes that this comes from his own statement and that no build log has been published. So treat it as a claim, not a verified fact.

The reality check

Here is where the story gets interesting, because the evidence points in two directions. On its own page, the PhotoCraft team says it opens and saves layered PSD files, with 134 of 135 real-world test files round-tripping byte for byte. It also lists support for CMYK and ICC color management.

Independent testing was less flattering. A hands-on review in mid-October found that PhotoCraft could not open iPhone HEIC photos and only offered JPEG export, with no way to save an editable project. In FilmCraft, clips couldn't be trimmed by dragging, and imported video audio played back as loud noise. The same review did note one striking fact: PhotoCraft weighed about 80 MB, against 6.4 GB for Photoshop on the same machine.

The two accounts may simply reflect timing. These apps are updating quickly, and a test from mid-October may already be out of date. What is not in dispute is Thomas's own description. He called the release "super early alpha," and he has softened his forecast from full parity within a month to a matter of months.

Why it matters even if it isn't ready

I don't think the interesting question is whether this beats Photoshop this year. It almost certainly doesn't. Adobe's real moat is decades of edge cases, file formats and professional trust, and a working skeleton of an app is a long way from that.

The interesting part is the clock. In roughly five weeks, one person went from nothing public to sixteen apps that install and run. Even if every one of them is rough, that changes what "starting a competitor" costs. There is also an open legal question: the claim that the code was written without copying protected material is the developer's own, and is not a legal guarantee.

Thomas has been quoted saying "software is over." I think that's overreach. But it's fair to say the barrier to attempting software has dropped, and incumbents that charge subscriptions for the hard parts will notice.

Sources: ArtCraft official site, BlogNT hands-on review (12 Oct 2026), reporting relayed via Ars Technica and Hacker News.

Enjoy reading on PBLISHD?

Bring your reading experience closer. Install PBLISHD on your device.